Most DJs suck?
Most DJs suck? Posted on: 01.10.2012 by Valeri Holderness Before you read this: by writing this I’m not saying that I’m some super crazy DJ, I still have a lot to learn myself. This is just something I’ve felt for a long time and I’d like to get some insight on how other people feel about this. Also, I’m talking mostly about club djing here.edit: after some discussion, i realized the thread title was a little misleading. just because a dj isn't technical doesn't make them a bad dj, and thats not what I'm going for here I got a chance to see dj spinbad and dj starting from scratch over the weekend (they played a set at a Russell Peters show). Their set was AMAZING and blew my mind. They were doing something truly artistic and were essentially making something new on stage. Slick cuts, juggling, acapellas, etc. It made me believe, why isn’t the standard for djs a little bit higher? Why aren’t big touring djs and resident djs expected to put some skill into what they do? Overall, I believe its safe to say that the majority of djs don’t really engage in the technical aspects of djing; they don’t necessarily “make” something new, they often just beat match between two tunes and call it a day. Some people like to pat themselves on the back for beatmatching, phase matching, phrase matching, etc. but as A-trak said: no one ever complimented a dj on how artistically they beat match. Spending a week learning basic beat matching and having an interest in a specific genre of music (which is something virtually something everyone has) is basically enough to make a mix that would be considered “acceptable”. I find that a lot of djs just reach this acceptable level and then don't feel the need to learn beyond that. Does anyone else see a problem with this? Everyone complains about aoki, guetta, etc. jut hitting play, but how many regular djs do anything more than that? Along with this, its almost become the standard for people to believe of djs as “record player players”. I was reading the paper this morning and the review of the show stated “also appearing was DJ Sarting from Scratch and DJ Spinbad but neither brought much to the evening as canned music would have easily filled the same role”. After perhaps dj craze, these guys played the craziest set I’ve seen in my life. Tonnes of live mashes, cutting etc. between each other all by ear. They were incredibly technical and not messy in the slightest. Also they were about 20 feet away from eachother so they couldn’t communicate or screen peak. Because we’ve set the standard so low, DJs who are actually talented don’t get the props they deserve. Because the majority of DJs themselves are ok with being at the "acceptable" level (and don't strive to do anything necessarily creative), people don't seem to make a distinction between a quality dj and your average joe. sorry for the novel, just something I wanted to discuss here opinions? | |
Julian Ispas 11.10.2012 | hella fun to watch, i bet it probably took some dedication, longggg studio days to get to the level he's at |
11.10.2012 | FWIW I've seen Kissy Sellout play and whilst he was amazing technically, his music made me want to stick screwdrivers in my ears, it's like it had ADD which is not nice. |
Rochel Papillion 11.10.2012 | |guess this is he level of technicality ya want to see more people reach |
Darren Teboe 09.10.2012 | Thanks for being a spam bot. I'm sure no one will benefit from it. |
Shaina Sulick 09.10.2012 | Thanks for sharing this information. I am sure lot of people will benefit from it. |
Darren Teboe 08.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by Claude485
Originally Posted by Claude485
Originally Posted by Claude485
|
Julian Ispas 08.10.2012 | people just need KEEP practicing, never be satisfy with where you are, always move foward. video above ^^^ is very good, but that doesn't say the whole story. you can practice then routine endless and then record yourself, so pretty much going through the motion. but it does take some better-ing yourself to come up with new stuff. so learn from others, compare yourself with people better than you not people less creative. practice practice and be dedicated. most people dj's are probably hobbies, and they don't put it as a priorities....while others this is their job 40 hours+/week on that instruments. so of course they are good. so give them average joe's a break....but if one is cocky about their no skills dj-ing, then let them have it. everything comes with time...but if your a bit talented...you just get to that level a little quicker. but hard work most of the times run neck to neck with being talented. |
Valeri Holderness 08.10.2012 | heh sorta related to the topic, i suppose some people can't even bother to dj themselves. today my friend found someone on youtube that was taking some of my mixes and putting his name on them. unfortunately not the first time its happened either -_- heres are some of his videos. basically just took my name off and put his on it. wtf? |
Freida Leash 08.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by sobi
|
Darren Teboe 07.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by rdale
|
Valeri Holderness 07.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by Patch
|
Brunilda Kora 07.10.2012 | No-one that posts here is qualified to comment on DJ Spinbad's technique. |
Valeri Holderness 07.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by djfil007
|
Arlinda Finazzo 07.10.2012 | Wow this thread is still going? Just wanted to respond now that I had chance to see the DJ's in the OP's post... Spinbad and Starting From Scratch, the touring DJ's for Russel Peters. I was impressed with the sync that they both have as a 2x4 setup, especially when they are on opposite sides of the stage. That said their mixing style was simplistic, mostly using quick cuts\drops, and then on top is quality scratching and few other juggling techniques... but that's almost the norm for 'top 40 mash-up' style that they play. It seemed that they had an exact formula being followed... like exactly on end of bar 4, it's scratch for distraction followed by an instant cut/drop to the next track. Few other things I did notice... the songs (all be it with the classic and current top 40 hooks, vocals, etc) they were all house/breaks edits (maybe even just the vocals on top of basic tracks/loops... maybe using serato bridge?). It also sounded like they never moved off a set BPM for the entire 30+ minutes I got to listen (which sure does make the distant 2x4 setup and quick mixing style a lot easier). It's not something I would pay to see on it's own... but for a general crowd (like warming up for a big stage comedy show) it works just fine. |
Freida Leash 07.10.2012 | There really is nothing wrong with dropping a top 10... personally I don't do it and enjoy digging a little deeper, finding new and old stuff, but that is about my passion for music, not about dj'ing. If the guy gets gigs playing the hits, more power to him, they are the "hits" for a reason, and I'm sure he probably gets decent response doing it? He might even have a passion for the top 10 beatport list. I believe 70% of my music gathering has been bootlegs and self released free tracks from artists bandcamp, facebook or soundcloud this past month. The tracks I have bought have probably been mostly influenced by those labels and producers. Even in the way back, there were a few great producers, that had weak DJ skills, but every dubplate worth having, well in advance. I never had the feeling that I was getting ripped off going to hear them, I knew I wasn't going to hear well developed mixing or tight turntablism that you might get at an Andy C or Danny the Wildchild, but I was always pleased to hear their selections. |
Audrey Pinda 07.10.2012 | DJing in and of itself, is also subjective. That's something that is being overlooked here. Some people don't want to hear something completely pushing the envelope, they just want to hear good tracks mixed fluidly. While others want to be surprised by different things. We, as DJ's, are the biggest snobs when it comes to what we like... because that's our job. It's also good because there are different evening s, and different niches for the different styles people bring to the table. I'll admit I absolutely hate the "top 10 beatport" rinsed and repeat week after week (yes, a DJ at a local club I go to honestly just does that week in and week out). And I believe that's the important thing. You can TELL when someone is putting love and effort into their mixes. You can TELL when they really don't give a flying F*** and just are doing it for the popularity and/or money. The style that they choose to push? Whatever it is, they need to be going for it fully. People need to regain passion and ambition. This arbitrary mediocrity is terrible. |
Lina Rawie 06.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by IznremiX
In any form of music, the best (if you can even objectively choose a best) are often not the highest paid or most successful. I believe the more you get into a particular style of music or a particular area of art, the more you develop an appreciation for that art which in turn may change your mind about what you believe is good or bad. As DJs, most of us are serious music heads who also have an appreciation of the technical skills required to be a DJ, but Average Joe doesn't share the same level of appreciation. Celebrity culture is also a big part of it and going to see a big name DJ (even if they're like Paris Hilton and not really a DJ at all) feels like more of an event or "big evening out" for many people and so it creates a much bigger buzz compared to going to see a local DJ, even if that local DJ is much better. In short - support your local scene and forget these celebrity clowns! |
Valeri Holderness 05.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by Solitaire
|
Rochel Papillion 04.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by LoopCat
|
Lillia Datson 04.10.2012 | I agree with OP on most of it. Ive seen some DJ's trying to fit far too much into their set however, and others not enough. Some of the best DJ's ives seen have two tracks, some simple effects and they sound amazing. Some cut and chop 8 different tracks which sounds equally amazing. I suppose if your tracks selections good, and your confident you can smash a party then your a good DJ whatever you do. |
04.10.2012 | I'm posting in here because someone bigged up KiNK. |
Ming Devis 04.10.2012 | Jamie is OK his nu disco/house sound is a bit old though. Seth is cool and plays some good music the times I've seen him and his productions are pretty sweet. Wouldn't call them ground breaking amazing DJ's lots of better guys out there. |
Rochel Papillion 04.10.2012 | What you consider Jamie Jones? or seth Troxler. I do not know much about them (yet) just been looking thru the residenta advisor top 100 and they are like 1 n 2 respectively http://www.be-at.tv/brands/mint-fest...jamie-jones.go |
Ming Devis 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by sobi
|
Louanne Andrix 03.10.2012 |
At least I'm not this bad |
Rochel Papillion 03.10.2012 | Maybe a little competition? People provide tracks and then tracks are voted for a list for a tracklist and everyone gets to make a mix of the tracks provided in the tracklist... |
Darren Teboe 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by DJSigma
Originally Posted by sobi
|
Ming Devis 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by DJSigma
|
Cole Maroto 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by IznremiX
i still agree that everyone should try to improve themselves, but the reality isn't always that simple when you factor in the real world with day jobs, deadlines, kids, bills, and and the pressures of life. sometimes you just want to grab a drink, get behind the decks, mix some good tracks together, and let the headaches of the day go by simply grooving along. |
Lina Rawie 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by AllDay
There are non-DJs that appreciate what DJs do, outside of just playing songs and doing basic mixing. They are outnumbered by those who "just wanna get drunk and dance to some good tunes", but they still exist and depending on what type of gigs you play, the ratio varies. I would rather try and satisfy everyone in the room then play to the lowest common denominator, but I'm doing it because I want to though - not because I feel I have to. That's why I believe these conversations are almost pointless when it comes to changing peoples' minds.
Originally Posted by IznremiX
EDIT - Oh yeah, and I don't believe that a DJ "sucks" if they're not doing technical stuff. If the crowd is happy, you don't suck. I would just like to see hip-hop DJs in particular pushing to get better technically, particularly as hip-hop was once looked upon as a genre where you would expect to hear the DJ flexing a few technical skills on the decks. |
Valeri Holderness 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by DJSigma
|
Valeri Holderness 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by AllDay
|
Tera Baragan 03.10.2012 | As long as your making people move and dance.. Your doing your job. |
Lina Rawie 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by LoopCat
|
Ming Devis 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by DJSigma
with Techno and House. Some people seem to believe this takes no skill which I believe is wrong. Its one thing to try and progress with technical skill but it needs to be done tastefully with respect to the tracks and genre otherwise it sounds like cheese |
Lina Rawie 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by LoopCat
EDIT - BTW, what makes me spit venom in topics like this, lol, is the standard of hip-hop DJing these days. That's what I'm into and so I hate to see it in the sorry state it's in. I have no idea what the standard is like for EDM DJs as I don't go and hear them play and I don't download their mixes, but the same thing applies to all DJs IMO. A good DJ will experiment with the features his/her gear has to offer, be it scratching, effects, loops, triggering samples, creating layers - whatever. Experiment with that stuff and a DJ may just find subtle uses for those things that they may once have written off as "useless" or "gimmicky" and that will help make them a better DJ and set them apart from the rest of the pack. They may not find a use for those things and continue to write them all off, but at least they tried. |
Ming Devis 03.10.2012 | It depends what scene you're into. Hip Hop guys are going love dj's who scratch like a champ. Deep House and Techno guys are going to enjoy a DJ who digs deep into his collection and picks amazing tune to fit the moment while mixing perfectly and creatively. Electro and Bro Step guys love the DJ's who create massive build ups with effects... A good DJ respects tracks. 99.9% of the time a Deep House dj will not scratch or use effects, they usually sound dumb with this style of music. A good Hip Hop dj will probably throw in some scratching here or there when it fits. |
Lina Rawie 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by Woah
Let's say there are 2 hip-hop DJs that are given the same 20 tracks to mix. DJ 1 makes a mix by just doing the same basic blend from one track to the next - no frills mixing. DJ 2 makes a mix where he uses different transition techniques and he throws in a little bit of scratching here and a little bit of trick mixing there. I'm gonna take DJ 2's mix over DJ 1's every time because it's the technical skill that sets them apart in that instance. You can't just use music as the deciding factor, especially as a lot of DJs are out there rinsing the same tunes anyway. Even if I hear a mix where a DJ has dug really deep for tunes and his track selection is absolutely amazing, if he is just doing basic blends then I'm gonna believe "I loved the tunes, but it would have been better if this guy was more technically skilled". From best to worst: - 1. Great track selection + great tech skills 2. Great track selection + poor tech skills 3. Poor track selection + great tech skills 4. Poor track selection + poor tech skills There's a lot of people out there who are happy to be in category 2 instead of pushing to be in category 1, but 1 is where you really wanna be it if you want to be thought of as great. A jukebox in the corner of a room can entertain a crowd. I'm into hip-hop, so I rarely listen to EDM mixes, but I do check out a lot of hip-hop mixes and IMO the average standard (relatively speaking) has never been lower in the 25+ years I've been listening to mixes. Some of the current top tier guys are the best there's ever been, but the average is dragged down by all these people putting no effort in. People who wouldn't even be DJs if they had to learn on turntables because it would be too much effort. People whose idea of "digging" is looking at the best seller charts on websites that sell MP3s. I'm fully aware that a DJ with minimal skill can get paid DJ work, but that doesn't mean that other DJs should be promoting the attitude that minimal skill is all you need, otherwise the bar just gets lower and lower. |
Valeri Holderness 03.10.2012 |
Originally Posted by Woah
|
Devora Chait 03.10.2012 | I mix techno and I'm not going to scratch during my performance, thank you. @ Sobi, a boring, run of the mill DJ? Because I don't alter my tracks enough? I don't scratch enough? Creativity is subjective, and I choose to be creative in other ways then that. I don't just show up and spin some toons, I learn to know my tracks very well beforehand and don't just mix from a to b, i blend alot, add things here and there, but other then that, I believe timing and track selection is the most important feature. I'm not really looking at features I don't find neccesary when I'm happy with my performance. I'd rather focus on the actual substance of a mix then trying to add all kinds of technical shit which basically is a gimick at best most of the time. |
<< Back to General DiscussionReply