Korg Nano series Vs Kontrol X1

Home :: Reviews of DJ equipment :: Korg Nano series Vs Kontrol X1Reply
Korg Nano series Vs Kontrol X1
Posted on: 25.01.2011 by Eunice Howe
Still considering my choices

So im wondering for a 2 deck simple controllerism setup something like the Kontrol X1 and Audio 2 + Mixer would work fine right? something cheap to get my feet wet in controllerism before i chuck a good
Eunice Howe
28.01.2011
Originally Posted by slpower01
i had nano kontrol for a week and the faders started messing up sending shitty signals, took it back and swapped for a nanopad the same week ean bought out the we will rock you video and was all excited about this, after 2 weeks the top row of pads all tiggerd there own pad and pad number 4 and 5 and messed up, go for the x1 the korg are shit!!
Yeh im past the nano now i read some reviews about it and they say similiar things

Rebelieveing once again i believe 2 x APC20 would be enough because i could use buttons as faders one button up one button down then some kills, not the most efficient setup but keeps it a little more simple

so Apc20 x 2 -> Laptop -> Audio 2 -> headphones/Main out

Each APC20 mapped for two decks + Mixer controls

Transport, 8 cues, Loops, Effects, EQ H/M/L + Kills and more
Eunice Howe
28.01.2011
Originally Posted by tyfurious
Wait... How much control do you want? The less you have mapped the more you can do quickly. I'd take a lauchpad and a nanokontrol before I'd go to apc's (no power chords, light weight, slimmer and can be transported in a soft bag. Even better, use Katapult and you could only use a launchpad.

Less is more, you want to be able to use all functionality quickly and easily.

Edit: My xone 2d is fair for 2 decks, combined with a Midifighters it's overkill (a bit, not a whole lot though). I feel as if a apc 20 would be good, but a slight overkill. If you don't mind the overkill go for it, but be ready to have a few to many buttons to press and remember what they do.
I was believeing apc20 and nanokontrol to start with so i was'nt far off

I prefer more controls than shift+controls but i see what you're saying

And Overkill is my middle name
Gilma Marchini
26.01.2011
Originally Posted by Fail
Wow Thanks for all the advice

Another idea....

Even more expensive but bound to give me what im after

Apc 20 + Midi controller + Apc20 -> Usb to
Laptop -> Audio 2 -> Headphones + Main out

Use each apc20 for 2 decks each and 2 banks of advanced effects with channel volume controls then use all the buttons sections for transport, hot cues, fx1-4, all that stuff full set for each deck no compromize on space

Then the middle midi control for 4 deck eq (assuming i find the right controller possibly make one) as a internal mixer instead of spending cash on an audio 8 and all singing all dancing 4 channel mixer that i only want for eq

Its not the most expensive setup and having 2 x apc 20 is probebly overkill you could argue i could use a shift function for decks C-D but i want all my buttons infront of me

I hate choices
You couldn't bring all that in a club and do the gig without having issues. If I'm correct apc's need a power chord too, whoch would be a bitch to hook up. Functionality of the setup would be sick though.

I'd get a Xone 1d before a APC. 0.o
Gilma Marchini
26.01.2011
Originally Posted by Conall
lets be honest though, midifighters dont really have much functionality if you dont hot cue juggle like ean, if your just using it as a normal midi controller you may aswell have a cheap drum pad or something of the sort and save yourself some money.
A MPD would be nice. You can pick one of those up for the price of an X1. Adds faders and size for about the same price if you get the MPD24... If your going the BeatPad route you might as well get a quality pad controller.
Inez Marcinik
26.01.2011
Originally Posted by padi_04
go for the x1, it's tank built (nano's don't like heavy hands), buttons have a better feel (pads in the kontrol series suck) and you get led feedback that responds to what is happening in the software. if you don't like the original mapping you can always edit it to fit your needs. watch the 7 Sonic Academy videos to fully understand the mapping. (click on the video title to watch the rest)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlN1lZGeUsM

you do have more controls to map if you buy the nano series, IMO opinion it reduces to a) more control vs b) intelligent control and durability.

ps: I'm 6ft 5", button size is fine

wow thanks for that, those videos is really good. Iv looked into x1's loads but those videos showed me loads of stuff i didnt know about it. I knew the mapping was well laid out but holy shit, im DEFINATELY getting one now.
Eunice Howe
25.01.2011		Still considering my choices

So im wondering for a 2 deck simple controllerism setup something like the Kontrol X1 and Audio 2 + Mixer would work fine right? something cheap to get my feet wet in controllerism before i chuck a good
Eunice Howe
28.01.2011
Originally Posted by slpower01
i had nano kontrol for a week and the faders started messing up sending shitty signals, took it back and swapped for a nanopad the same week ean bought out the we will rock you video and was all excited about this, after 2 weeks the top row of pads all tiggerd there own pad and pad number 4 and 5 and messed up, go for the x1 the korg are shit!!
Yeh im past the nano now i read some reviews about it and they say similiar things

Rebelieveing once again i believe 2 x APC20 would be enough because i could use buttons as faders one button up one button down then some kills, not the most efficient setup but keeps it a little more simple

so Apc20 x 2 -> Laptop -> Audio 2 -> headphones/Main out

Each APC20 mapped for two decks + Mixer controls

Transport, 8 cues, Loops, Effects, EQ H/M/L + Kills and more
Loralee Erban
27.01.2011		i had nano kontrol for a week and the faders started messing up sending shitty signals, took it back and swapped for a nanopad the same week ean bought out the we will rock you video and was all excited about this, after 2 weeks the top row of pads all tiggerd there own pad and pad number 4 and 5 and messed up, go for the x1 the korg are shit!!
Eunice Howe
28.01.2011
Originally Posted by tyfurious
Wait... How much control do you want? The less you have mapped the more you can do quickly. I'd take a lauchpad and a nanokontrol before I'd go to apc's (no power chords, light weight, slimmer and can be transported in a soft bag. Even better, use Katapult and you could only use a launchpad.

Less is more, you want to be able to use all functionality quickly and easily.

Edit: My xone 2d is fair for 2 decks, combined with a Midifighters it's overkill (a bit, not a whole lot though). I feel as if a apc 20 would be good, but a slight overkill. If you don't mind the overkill go for it, but be ready to have a few to many buttons to press and remember what they do.
I was believeing apc20 and nanokontrol to start with so i was'nt far off

I prefer more controls than shift+controls but i see what you're saying

And Overkill is my middle name
Gilma Marchini
27.01.2011		Wait... How much control do you want? The less you have mapped the more you can do quickly. I'd take a lauchpad and a nanokontrol before I'd go to apc's (no power chords, light weight, slimmer and can be transported in a soft bag. Even better, use Katapult and you could only use a launchpad.

Less is more, you want to be able to use all functionality quickly and easily.

Edit: My xone 2d is fair for 2 decks, combined with a Midifighters it's overkill (a bit, not a whole lot though). I feel as if a apc 20 would be good, but a slight overkill. If you don't mind the overkill go for it, but be ready to have a few to many buttons to press and remember what they do.
Eunice Howe
27.01.2011		The same way i plan to lug around my turntables and mixer.... in a flight case

The apc20's are alot smaller and as i said above its not planned for the clubs yet not until i work out redundancy issues with the laptops and pc i use and make sure my mapping is efficient and not to confusing with all the buttons(can't have me dropping or BSOD during a set)

The apc is just short of 30cm wide so 60cm wide + 20cm max for mixer controls + a laptop to the side or if necessary on a stand infront of it is hardly taking up alot of room ...
Kiyoko Wellisch
27.01.2011		Because how do you intend to lug those about and where the hell do you expect to put them all?
Eunice Howe
27.01.2011		How come? Is it because there two of the same controllers?

Its not truelly planned for a club anyway atleast not yet... i would need to work on some redundancy issues with my laptop and such before i attempted the clubs

As you say functionality would be sick just an endless amount of control on traktor is what im after

The 1d looks great but still not enough controls i could live with a little bit of button mashing to switch controls but i would much prefer a full array infront of me no mashing


As for power i was believeing of making my own flightcase for them one on each side with the mixer controls centre like normal with possibly somewhere underneith for the audio 2 and a powerstrip with surge protection etc
Gilma Marchini
26.01.2011
Originally Posted by Fail
Wow Thanks for all the advice

Another idea....

Even more expensive but bound to give me what im after

Apc 20 + Midi controller + Apc20 -> Usb to
Laptop -> Audio 2 -> Headphones + Main out

Use each apc20 for 2 decks each and 2 banks of advanced effects with channel volume controls then use all the buttons sections for transport, hot cues, fx1-4, all that stuff full set for each deck no compromize on space

Then the middle midi control for 4 deck eq (assuming i find the right controller possibly make one) as a internal mixer instead of spending cash on an audio 8 and all singing all dancing 4 channel mixer that i only want for eq

Its not the most expensive setup and having 2 x apc 20 is probebly overkill you could argue i could use a shift function for decks C-D but i want all my buttons infront of me

I hate choices
You couldn't bring all that in a club and do the gig without having issues. If I'm correct apc's need a power chord too, whoch would be a bitch to hook up. Functionality of the setup would be sick though.

I'd get a Xone 1d before a APC. 0.o
Eunice Howe
27.01.2011		Wow Thanks for all the advice

Another idea....

Even more expensive but bound to give me what im after

Apc 20 + Midi controller + Apc20 -> Usb to
Laptop -> Audio 2 -> Headphones + Main out

Use each apc20 for 2 decks each and 2 banks of advanced effects with channel volume controls then use all the buttons sections for transport, hot cues, fx1-4, all that stuff full set for each deck no compromize on space

Then the middle midi control for 4 deck eq (assuming i find the right controller possibly make one) as a internal mixer instead of spending cash on an audio 8 and all singing all dancing 4 channel mixer that i only want for eq

Its not the most expensive setup and having 2 x apc 20 is probebly overkill you could argue i could use a shift function for decks C-D but i want all my buttons infront of me

I hate choices
Gilma Marchini
26.01.2011
Originally Posted by Conall
lets be honest though, midifighters dont really have much functionality if you dont hot cue juggle like ean, if your just using it as a normal midi controller you may aswell have a cheap drum pad or something of the sort and save yourself some money.
A MPD would be nice. You can pick one of those up for the price of an X1. Adds faders and size for about the same price if you get the MPD24... If your going the BeatPad route you might as well get a quality pad controller.
Corey Tronchin
26.01.2011		I'd go for the kontrol x1 too. I have both actually, but I would never consider using the nano units for serious djing. I just like to have them on the side as a plaything and when i temporary need buttons/sliders/knobs to work out an idea. Then, after I finalized the idea I head over to the kontrol X1 and figure out how to project it on that one.
Inez Marcinik
26.01.2011		lets be honest though, midifighters dont really have much functionality if you dont hot cue juggle like ean, if your just using it as a normal midi controller you may aswell have a cheap drum pad or something of the sort and save yourself some money.
Gilma Marchini
26.01.2011		X1 would seem to be the rational choice... Although I personally would vouch against it. The buttons are too small for my big 'ol magician hands (good for hiding things and bumping the wrong button), the knobs where the highlight of the controller, and using the case as a stand felt weird. I would even use a Akai MPD 24, save up and get MidiFighters, or some other controller you could creatively map yourself before using an X1.

Everyone else seems to love the X1, I guess I'm the only guy who just didn't like it around here.
Latoria Kavulich
26.01.2011		Doooo ittttt
Inez Marcinik
26.01.2011
Originally Posted by padi_04
go for the x1, it's tank built (nano's don't like heavy hands), buttons have a better feel (pads in the kontrol series suck) and you get led feedback that responds to what is happening in the software. if you don't like the original mapping you can always edit it to fit your needs. watch the 7 Sonic Academy videos to fully understand the mapping. (click on the video title to watch the rest)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlN1lZGeUsM

you do have more controls to map if you buy the nano series, IMO opinion it reduces to a) more control vs b) intelligent control and durability.

ps: I'm 6ft 5", button size is fine

wow thanks for that, those videos is really good. Iv looked into x1's loads but those videos showed me loads of stuff i didnt know about it. I knew the mapping was well laid out but holy shit, im DEFINATELY getting one now.
Inez Marcinik
26.01.2011		yeah the nano's have pretty bad build quality, i got a nanokontrol for alongside traktor scratch for effects and cue points (no mad cue point juggling obviously) and im definately gonna upgrade to an x1 at some point, nano's just arnt built well enough and dont have enough functionality for a club enviroment.
Len Ladera
25.01.2011		Kontrol X1. LEDs, tightly integrated.
Chas Giraldez
25.01.2011		Personally, I Got an x1 when facing this decision. the thing is made for traktor down to the very last detail and its rock solid.
if you have to go the low cost route, get the akai lpd 8 instead of the korg nano pad. its built much better and costs about the same
Nedra Fresneda
25.01.2011		go for the x1, it's tank built (nano's don't like heavy hands), buttons have a better feel (pads in the kontrol series suck) and you get led feedback that responds to what is happening in the software. if you don't like the original mapping you can always edit it to fit your needs. watch the 7 Sonic Academy videos to fully understand the mapping. (click on the video title to watch the rest)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlN1lZGeUsM

you do have more controls to map if you buy the nano series, IMO opinion it reduces to a) more control vs b) intelligent control and durability.

ps: I'm 6ft 5", button size is fine

<< Back to Reviews of DJ equipment Reply

Copyright 2012-2023
DJRANKINGS.ORG n.g.o.
Chuo-ku, Osaka, Japan

Created by Ajaxel CMS

Terms & Privacy