Reply to Misbehaving modifiers

Edited for derpy typo:

I'm trying to make an 8 state modifier cycle button, for selecting sample slots. It worked fine, inc from 0 to 7, and on 7 the next press direct back to 0. Then I switched the button I'm using to do it from the loop knob to loop in. Now, it goes back to 1, like its doing the direct, then incrementing. what gives?

here are screenshots of the relevant modifiers:

scrn 1.jpg
scrn 2.jpg