Reply to Behringer 112d or Alto 112a for college parties

Hi, just registered here, been subbed to the channel for a while though.

I'm able to get either a behringer 112d or alto 112a at almost exactly the same price. I'm only getting one, it's for college parties. I use a kontrol S2 but the speaker will also be used just for music from peoples phones etc. The room is pretty small, just a living room in a townhouse.

I'm wondering which speaker would be better. Durability, loudness, and bass is pretty important obviously