Genre Question

Home :: General Discussion :: Genre QuestionReply
Genre Question
Posted on: 21.11.2013 by Maryam Fevold
Hey guys,

Just a random thought/question. With everything getting classified and re-classified into subgenres these days, especially with house music, what's the consensus for the style house music with artists like DJ Dan, Phunk Investigation, My Digital Enemy, etc etc. Certainly hi-energy, but I wouldn't call it big room (i.e. progressive or electro). Is it just kind of referred to as house or straight house?
Hellen Mindrup
22.11.2013
Originally Posted by deevey
Thought you American folks labeled everything un-genrable with a beat "EDM" these days
Here in Chicago we still have a real scene, not everyone here is "EDM" like the rest of the country
Evalyn Voges
22.11.2013
Originally Posted by Sambo
It's what the chav's next door to me when I grew up used to say. See hard house has BPMs akin or even faster than trance, so it's a pretty good reference point. It's also why most people say prog house isn't really house, because it uses all the trademarks of trance but at fast house tempos, and as a fan of house and not trance and not a fan of prog house, I totally agree.
I could pull up some Trance tracks with slower BPM than House right now, if you want. BPM is irrelevant for genres. Just go with what genre you believe the track is...
Jetta Drenzek
21.11.2013
Originally Posted by SlvrDragon50
Rofl. I believe BPM is an easier way to tell trance vs house.

Never really thought about that though.
It's what the chav's next door to me when I grew up used to say. See hard house has BPMs akin or even faster than trance, so it's a pretty good reference point. It's also why most people say prog house isn't really house, because it uses all the trademarks of trance but at fast house tempos, and as a fan of house and not trance and not a fan of prog house, I totally agree.
Gaynell Rydberg
21.11.2013
Originally Posted by Sambo
Snare -> House
No snare -> Trance
Rofl. I believe BPM is an easier way to tell trance vs house.

Never really thought about that though.
Latoria Kavulich
21.11.2013
Originally Posted by Kwal
Falls under "house" if you can't identify it correctly lol
yep or just go by bpm
Maryam Fevold
21.11.2013
Hey guys,

Just a random thought/question. With everything getting classified and re-classified into subgenres these days, especially with house music, what's the consensus for the style house music with artists like DJ Dan, Phunk Investigation, My Digital Enemy, etc etc. Certainly hi-energy, but I wouldn't call it big room (i.e. progressive or electro). Is it just kind of referred to as house or straight house?
Hellen Mindrup
22.11.2013
Originally Posted by deevey
Thought you American folks labeled everything un-genrable with a beat "EDM" these days
Here in Chicago we still have a real scene, not everyone here is "EDM" like the rest of the country
Evalyn Voges
22.11.2013
Originally Posted by Sambo
It's what the chav's next door to me when I grew up used to say. See hard house has BPMs akin or even faster than trance, so it's a pretty good reference point. It's also why most people say prog house isn't really house, because it uses all the trademarks of trance but at fast house tempos, and as a fan of house and not trance and not a fan of prog house, I totally agree.
I could pull up some Trance tracks with slower BPM than House right now, if you want. BPM is irrelevant for genres. Just go with what genre you believe the track is...
Jetta Drenzek
21.11.2013
Originally Posted by SlvrDragon50
Rofl. I believe BPM is an easier way to tell trance vs house.

Never really thought about that though.
It's what the chav's next door to me when I grew up used to say. See hard house has BPMs akin or even faster than trance, so it's a pretty good reference point. It's also why most people say prog house isn't really house, because it uses all the trademarks of trance but at fast house tempos, and as a fan of house and not trance and not a fan of prog house, I totally agree.
Rolanda Clodfelder
21.11.2013
Falls under "house" if you can't identify it correctly lol
Thought you American folks labeled everything un-genrable with a beat "EDM" these days
Gaynell Rydberg
21.11.2013
Originally Posted by Sambo
Snare -> House
No snare -> Trance
Rofl. I believe BPM is an easier way to tell trance vs house.

Never really thought about that though.
Jetta Drenzek
21.11.2013
Snare -> House
No snare -> Trance
Latoria Kavulich
21.11.2013
Originally Posted by Kwal
Falls under "house" if you can't identify it correctly lol
yep or just go by bpm
Hellen Mindrup
21.11.2013
Falls under "house" if you can't identify it correctly lol
Antonetta Wikel
21.11.2013
Same with DJ Dan, he's produced some really hard tracks, some disco tracks, funky tracks (this seems his latest groove). I also find certain artists produce different styles based on the Label they'll put the track out on.
Alphonso Deitchman
21.11.2013
It depends on the individual track too. I've just listened to some Phunk Investigation and a few tracks were techno, some were electro, and another was almost disco.
Maryam Fevold
21.11.2013
Point taken - but whether those classifications make a lot of sense or not, sometimes they can be useful. Just wondering how other people referred to that style of house in conversation, or when marketing themselves, etc.
Latoria Kavulich
21.11.2013
ignore the sub genre classifications, they are just marketing labels mate. i tag all my house tracks as either funky, tech or progressive.

<< Back to General DiscussionReply

Copyright 2012-2023
DJRANKINGS.ORG n.g.o.
Chuo-ku, Osaka, Japan

Created by Ajaxel CMS

Terms & Privacy