Recommend me a keyboard/synth for piano lessons.

Home :: General Discussion :: Recommend me a keyboard/synth for piano lessons.Reply
Recommend me a keyboard/synth for piano lessons.
Posted on: 07.09.2013 by Nereida Jasnoch
So I have a years worth of piano lessons lined up starting next friday. I want to do this because I want to get more comfortable with coming up with my own melodies when producing and music theory.

The teacher recommends I buy this:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_psr_e243_set.htm
It has MIDI out for PC and iOS but not for Mac (is that even possible ?) and I have a MBP

But thought it 'd be more fun to get an actual synth like a MicroKorg or MiniBrute (I believe these have aftertouch)
But maybe they don't have enough octaves...
Or at least get something that 'd be fun to use with ableton or something.


What would recommend ? (search on the community wasn't much help)
The music school that I go to is pretty alternative and loose, and we are really free in the music we want to play.
Nereida Jasnoch
07.09.2013
Originally Posted by makar1
You want something more like this for actual piano lessons:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_p35_b.htm

MIDI is not OS specific so any MIDI keyboard will work on Mac as well as Windows.
Yes I tought so, but it's weird that they mentioned PC and iOS in the promo vid and not Mac, also the site has drivers for iOS and PC, but then again it's quite likely that Mac does not require MIDI drivers
Doreen Schurle
07.09.2013
Originally Posted by makar1
You want something more like this for actual piano lessons:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_p35_b.htm

MIDI is not OS specific so any MIDI keyboard will work on Mac as well as Windows.
Agreed, you want a hammer-action fully weighted master keyboard for learning the piano. Traditional "keyboards" won't prepare you for using a piano and vice-versa. You can get second hand ones pretty reasonably provided you don't mind collecting them or having them couriered for about €150; you could even - if you've got the money - get something like the 88-key Korg Triton or Trinity, which combine a master keyboard with a pretty incredible prosynth.
Nereida Jasnoch
07.09.2013
So I have a years worth of piano lessons lined up starting next friday. I want to do this because I want to get more comfortable with coming up with my own melodies when producing and music theory.

The teacher recommends I buy this:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_psr_e243_set.htm
It has MIDI out for PC and iOS but not for Mac (is that even possible ?) and I have a MBP

But thought it 'd be more fun to get an actual synth like a MicroKorg or MiniBrute (I believe these have aftertouch)
But maybe they don't have enough octaves...
Or at least get something that 'd be fun to use with ableton or something.


What would recommend ? (search on the community wasn't much help)
The music school that I go to is pretty alternative and loose, and we are really free in the music we want to play.
Lannie Kutay
09.09.2013
Im not a fan of fully weighted, but if you wanna do that than get this.

It is definitly a powerhouse, and will serve your production needs, for a long time, also weighted, hammer action keys.

http://www.guitarcenter.com/Akai-Pro...id^13625727881
Lakeesha Storman
07.09.2013
The keyboard recommended isn't a full keyboard either. Personally, I'd go with makar recommended. You can always get a small midi controller later for production and midi capabilities. As a piano player myself who took years of lessons and taught for a couple of years, weighted keys are absolutely huge in my book. You want to be able to become expressive with each keypress as you get better and understand the music better. I have a keyboard that I use for production, but when it comes to "just playing" I play on my piano and always felt the keyboard was lacking.

Your other option obviously is to go the keyboard route now and get a full weighted key piece later, but I believe learning with the weighted keys from the get go is the better option.
Nereida Jasnoch
07.09.2013
Originally Posted by makar1
You want something more like this for actual piano lessons:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_p35_b.htm

MIDI is not OS specific so any MIDI keyboard will work on Mac as well as Windows.
Yes I tought so, but it's weird that they mentioned PC and iOS in the promo vid and not Mac, also the site has drivers for iOS and PC, but then again it's quite likely that Mac does not require MIDI drivers
Nereida Jasnoch
07.09.2013
Yeah they aren't piano lessons per se. The teacher is a multi-instrumentalist and he asked do you want to go the piano route or the keyboard route or both ? And I said keyboard for the most part.

But I'm not entirely sure if I need to bring my instrument to the school all the time. They have digital pianos and keyboards at the school, but I assume it is encouraged to practice on one particular instrument.
Doreen Schurle
07.09.2013
Originally Posted by makar1
You want something more like this for actual piano lessons:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_p35_b.htm

MIDI is not OS specific so any MIDI keyboard will work on Mac as well as Windows.
Agreed, you want a hammer-action fully weighted master keyboard for learning the piano. Traditional "keyboards" won't prepare you for using a piano and vice-versa. You can get second hand ones pretty reasonably provided you don't mind collecting them or having them couriered for about €150; you could even - if you've got the money - get something like the 88-key Korg Triton or Trinity, which combine a master keyboard with a pretty incredible prosynth.
Alphonso Deitchman
07.09.2013
You want something more like this for actual piano lessons:
http://www.thomann.de/be/yamaha_p35_b.htm

MIDI is not OS specific so any MIDI keyboard will work on Mac as well as Windows.

<< Back to General DiscussionReply

Copyright 2012-2023
DJRANKINGS.ORG n.g.o.
Chuo-ku, Osaka, Japan

Created by Ajaxel CMS

Terms & Privacy