Reply to Top half of midi-fighter not working

Has anyone had an issue similar to this or know a fix? I had my midifighter working fine on my desktop (PC) in my apartment, and just brought it back home to CT to mess around with it on my brothers Mac and the bottom 8 buttons work fine, but the top 8 get no response in the Audio Midi Setup, and pressing the right-most button in the second row lights up all top 8, and no other button lights up anything in the top 8.

I tried re-flashing the firmware, and tried on my Windows laptop here now too, same issue. Anyone have this happen or know how to fix it?