Reply to Vinyl alongside S4/VCI 400

So, I've got the itch to get an all in one controller. I'm still debating between the S4 and VCI 400. I'm coming from a vinyl background, but was robbed of all my gear except one of my 1200's. I'd like to play vinyl alongside a controller. Is the set up possible? What problems will I run into? Which controller is more ideal for my situation? I don't scratch and I really prefer the lay out of the VCI 400. It just seems more traditional.

I wish the NS 7 was 3 channels as that would probably be my ideal controller.